Issue #21 · Pixel-craft material QA

Matched gameplay views

Before · PR #27 scene with existing textures

After · PR #29 material textures with the PR #27 Storybook scene

Scene source: a66121c35895b6e716cfe150b16f5197f9f4f3b8
Material source: PR #29 head 5a1bb7401bfc977461e8f992092a3343359590c8 · seed 1337

Captured in the same Codex in-app desktop browser at 1280 × 720 after resetting both pages to the same seed and view. Gameplay and temporary block samples were held only in each page’s memory; they were not saved or sent over the network.

Before · complete block-family sheet

Baseline texture source: 10c7bb44540e83dc54c062b4ba855183fb1c5eef (blocks 1–21).

After · complete block-family sheet

Current sheet covers all non-air blocks 1–24. Blocks 22–24 were added after the baseline.

Gameplay-distance observations and limits

• At the matched first-person spawn view, the cobble path, grass, hut masonry, logs, foliage, flowers, and animals are present in both builds. The after view shows surface detail at this distance, with stronger flecks in the grass and wood/leaf texture.
• Gold and Glowstone were placed temporarily in both preview pages on the path and inspected from a few blocks away. Gold reads as a warm ochre block with darker ore-like marks. Glowstone’s cyan field and bright star are easy to pick out under the current lighting.
• The seed 1337 scene contains a flowing stream. From a lower free-camera view its blue surface is visible, but this run did not capture glass or ice at normal gameplay distance. Neither is available in the standard Play & Build hotbar or present in the sampled scene.
• The preview remains labeled “fixed dawn camera” and keeps a purple sky/pink haze with strong teal-green ground tint. The DAY NOW control did not produce a verifiable daylight scene here. No warm-sunset capture was obtained, so lighting-dependent readability for glass, ice, ores, and emissive/decor blocks remains incomplete.

No bounded texture edit was justified by this sample: the tested gold and Glowstone were distinguishable, while the unobserved materials and lighting states need evidence before palette changes can be judged.

Validation status

Automated checks: 234 passed across 23 suites, including block coverage, save behavior, performance regressions, and sanitized offline QA output. Independent contact-sheet review passed.

Browser sample in the same desktop in-app browser (hardware/GPU unavailable): before 1.7 FPS, p95 frame time 1016.2 ms, heap 21.8 MiB; after 5.3 FPS, 1007.3 ms, heap 22.6 MiB. The session was heavily throttled; these readings do not establish acceptable device performance.

Issue #21 is not accepted. Glass and ice gameplay-distance evidence, daylight/warm-sunset comparison, and a valid performance sample remain outstanding.

Contact sheets document texture inventory; they do not prove in-game readability.